BMW 5 Series: Years to Avoid and Best Years (Engine & Transmission)
BMW 5 Series problems by model year, from 449 owner complaints filed with NHTSA. For each year: the share of complaints about the engine, transmission or fuel system, how many there were, and the recalls.
Worst years to avoid: 2016 (81%, 55 drivetrain complaints), 2010 (70%, 105 drivetrain complaints) and 2019 (44%, 15 drivetrain complaints). 5 of the 5 BMW 5 Series years we score have an elevated engine, transmission or fuel-system complaint share; 2 of them are at the very high level (60% or more), where every model year we track has a documented failure behind it.
No BMW 5 Series year we score is clear of an elevated signal. The lowest is the 2021 (33%).
By raw volume, the 2010 drew the most drivetrain complaints (105 of 196 across the scored years). Volume also tracks how many were sold and how long they have been on the road, which is why the share, not the count, sets the verdict.
2022 and 2023 have fewer than 25 complaints on record so far, too few to score. Newer cars have had less time to collect complaints.
Engine and transmission complaint share, 2010–2023
Share of relevant owner complaints about the engine, transmission or fuel system. 33% is elevated, 40% high, 60% very high. A dash means too few complaints to score.
Every BMW 5 Series year
| Model year | Signal | Drivetrain share | Drivetrain complaints | All complaints | Rank (1 = worst) | Recalls |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2010 5 Series | very high | 70% | 105 | 180 | 2/5 | 2 |
| 2016 5 Series | very high | 81% | 55 | 83 | 1/5 | 0 |
| 2018 5 Series | elevated | 36% | 13 | 79 | 4/5 | 0 |
| 2019 5 Series | high | 44% | 15 | 39 | 3/5 | 0 |
| 2020 5 Series | too few to score | – | 6 | 15 | – | 0 |
| 2021 5 Series | elevated | 33% | 8 | 27 | 5/5 | 0 |
| 2022 5 Series | too few to score | – | 7 | 17 | – | 0 |
| 2023 5 Series | too few to score | – | 3 | 9 | – | 1 |
What owners complain about most, all years
Categories as NHTSA files them, summed across the BMW 5 Series years with data. A complaint can name more than one component, so the shares overlap. Red is engine, transmission or fuel.
BMW 5 Series engine recalls: timeline
NHTSA lists 2 recall campaigns on the BMW 5 Series involving the engine, transmission or fuel system, out of 2 across the years we track. Each model-year page has the details. Whether a particular car still has a recall open depends on its VIN.
| Date | Campaign | Component | Model years |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mar 2022 | 22V119000 | engine and engine cooling: exhaust system: emission control: crankcase (pcv) | 2010 |
| Oct 2023 | 23V707000 | engine and engine cooling: engine | 2010 |
What the free pages leave out on the BMW 5 Series
- The mileage where it happens, for the model year you are looking at.
- What the repair costs, to price into your offer.
- Cleaner alternatives: similar cars with a better record.
- Up to 15 owner reports, with the ones about your car's own engine first.
- What to ask the seller and what to check on the test drive.
- Open recalls on the actual car, by VIN.
Questions people ask about the BMW 5 Series
What are the worst years for the BMW 5 Series?
On engine and transmission complaints, the worst BMW 5 Series years are the 2016 (81% of relevant complaints, very high), the 2010 (70% of relevant complaints, very high) and the 2019 (44% of relevant complaints, high). 5 of 5 scored years are elevated in all.
What are the best years for the BMW 5 Series?
No BMW 5 Series year we score is below the 33% line. The lowest share is the 2021 (33%).
Does the BMW 5 Series have engine problems?
In some years. Across the 5 scored years, 196 of 312 relevant NHTSA complaints (63%) concern the engine, transmission or fuel system; the largest drivetrain category is engine. The years with an elevated share are 2010, 2016, 2018, 2019 and 2021.
Is the BMW 5 Series reliable?
On the engine and transmission it depends on the year: 5 of 5 BMW 5 Series years we score have an elevated complaint share and 0 do not. Pooled across those years, 63% of relevant complaints are about the drivetrain, against a 33% line for an elevated signal. Complaint data does not measure overall reliability, so pick the year first, then inspect the car.
Are there transmission or engine recalls on the BMW 5 Series?
Yes. NHTSA lists 2 recall campaigns involving the engine, transmission or fuel system across the BMW 5 Series years we track, out of 2 in total: 22V119000 (Mar 2022, 2010), 23V707000 (Oct 2023, 2010). Whether a car still has one open depends on its VIN.
Have the VIN?Paste it and get the full report for that car. First report free, then a 30-day pass covers a whole car search.
Check a VINExperimental model-level information. This is not a vehicle inspection, vehicle-history report, financial advice or purchase recommendation. It describes patterns across model years, not the condition of any individual vehicle. Model years with fewer than 25 complaints are not scored.